Help! Ideas? Hearthlings keep eating components before I can craft Donation to the Church of Plenty

Trying to craft a Donation to the Church of Plenty but before my freshly crafted Poyo Pot Pie or Rack of Mutton are even cooled they are eaten! I have the Donation queued up and waiting for the components… it’s just that at least one is always missing.

Thoughts on how I can get through this?

Hearthlings are set to eat cooked food over raw. Honestly the best way to make the donation is to have a stockpile of the ingredients and to set the donation to the top of your crafting list.

2 Likes

Have 2 cooks at the same time.

Also try making sure you have plenty of other cooked food for them, though I found they love meat over everything else so those items tend to go fast. Honestly, I don’t try to craft this until I know I have lots of veggie stew and meat stew stockpiled as it makes it less likely they’ll eat the donations while I make them both.

Two cooks is a good idea, too (with enough crafting stations for them). They’ll both prep one of the items at the same time.

OK thanks for the tips everyone!